St. Andrew's Episcopal Church

 

 

 

Capital Campaign - Drainage Project


 

For many years, St. Andrews Church has sustained water damage in the basement classrooms causing mildew, rot and damage to furnishings.  During the summer of 2008, a number of contractors were contacted to develop a permanent solution to recurrent water in the basement of the church.  These solutions were for inside work to address the problem – some of the estimates were as high as $250,000.  Obviously the church could not afford this amount of money and more importantly, the problem of water coming into the basement would not be eliminated.

The Properties Ministry decided to look into other solutions.  Measurements and rough calculations indicated that the probable cause was inability to carry surface water from rain storms away from the building at a rapid enough rate, thereby causing the water to back up into the basement.  During a thunderstorm, the water levels were observed and recorded in pictures to document what happened.  Observations confirmed that this was the primary cause of water coming into the basement.  The photos and analysis were shown to the parish in the Presentation of 12-14-2008 along with plans of the work necessary to correct the problem.

Click here to see the December 2008 Presentation 

(your browser will open a new window) 

Please note that some of the images may take a moment to load.

As an explanation, the original design of the church drainage provided a single dry well with about 20% of the capacity needed to drain the water from a typical thunderstorm.  The design life of dry wells is about 50 years allowing for silt buildup and roots blocking the water flow – both silt and roots were extreme in our dry well before correction.  This means the capacity had been greatly reduced from the design capacity to perhaps 10% of that needed to keep the basement dry.  Clearly this problem had to be corrected.

The church hired Schofield Brothers to perform a complete analysis and develop a design to handle the surface water runoff.  Using computer software to predict the 100 year storm, a design was developed for a complete church remediation plan.  To confirm the adequacy of the plan, a perk test was conducted at two points in the planned drainage area.  The perk test confirmed that the soil was sandy (providing good drainage capability) and that the water table was well below the level of the church basement floor and was not the cause of the water in the basement.  The plan was broken into 5 separate manageable parts.  Since the major problem was associated with the runoff on the north-east area of the church roof/driveway, etc, it was decided to focus on Phase A and its associated downspout connections (Phase C).

Bids were solicited from four (4) contractors to perform the necessary work.  The lowest bidder was D. J. Morris of Sudbury with whom a contract was signed to install the Phase A work.  The work was performed in the spring of 2009.  This resulted in a new water quality unit and a recharger field of about 50 feet by thirty feet, about 8 feet deep.  Water outflow from the existing drywell was routed to the new water quality unit.  The steps installing this are shown in photos A-01 through A-13.

Click here to open the above slideshow in a new window (you'll be able to view the pictures much larger)

The next step was to connect the downspouts to the new drainage system (Phase C) on the East side of the church.  Funds being short, it was decided to perform this work using church volunteers and subcontracted backhoe over two weekends during the summer.  This work is shown in photos C-01 through C-41.

As part of the overall project, the following corrective actions were also performed:

  • All window wells were dug out 6 to 8 inches below the sills and filled with stone.

  • Gutters and downspouts were installed on the Narthex at the front of the sanctuary.

  • The original drywell was dug out to the bottom (over 5 feet of sediment was removed).

  • All gutters and downspouts were removed and cleared of obstructions – wire strainers were installed at every downspout to prevent future clogging.

  • Both catch basins in the rear courtyard were rebuilt with concrete.

  • On the west side of the church, the long outriggers were removed and black top paving channels installed to direct water to the driveway area away from the building.

  • The grass was replanted over the affected areas and the cuts in the driveway were repaved.

Photographs, presentation and narrative by Peter Dunham.

 

Copyright 2001-2010 ~ St. Andrew's Episcopal Church, Framingham, MA.  All Rights Reserved.

Home

Website Design and Maintenance by